Issue 41: One of the only times your personal statement doesn’t matter as much

Everyone talks about college, but what if you just want to be an artist and entrepreneur? Do you even need to go to college? This week, I talked to former UC Irvine admissions ambassador and professional dancer and fitness instructor, Shira Jackman, who shared insights on her journey from a top California public school to her Broadway career in NYC.

I called Shira for our interview appointment one weekday afternoon. She picked up and I immediately heard sirens and trucks in the background. She was in New York City and I was on the opposite coast.

A week before I called Shira, I’d shown up to the UC Irvine admissions office, attempting to get an interview with an admissions officer there. I left without an interview. (Full story on that later.)

Throughout my local speaking tour this season, I’ve realized that parents want to learn more about the UC’s (a consortium of public 4-year research universities in California). So even before calling Shira, I was eager to report more on UCI, a top public research university in the safest city in America. Not to mention I’d grown up in the city, gone to summer camps there as a kid, and live just a short drive away.

Shira’s not the typical UCI grad one would expect and certainly not the type of interviewee I typically get to learn from. An entrepreneur and artist, she attributes much of her success to her training outside of college academia. I appreciated insight from someone who enjoyed her college experience and admissions work, but also realized that college wasn’t the only path she could’ve taken.

Exclusive Insider Interview: Former UC Irvine ambassador & professional dancer, Shira Jackman

Shira at UCI: I had a pretty unconventional path for what people probably expect. I currently live in New York City, and I am a professional dancer and a fitness professional.

Mercy at SocratesPost: How did your college experience, if at all, contribute to your professional career?

Shira at UCI: I ended up with degrees in Dance and Business Administration from UCI. And I’m obviously using the dance training that I got there. But also, as a dancer, and in the fitness industry, you’re freelance, and you’re pretty much an entrepreneur and using yourself as your brand. So I get to use a lot of my business skills as well.

Mercy at SocratesPost: How did you get involved with learning about the fitness industry? Was that something you did during college or after?

Shira at UCI: Not so much during college. I worked at my first gym in college, doing front desk work and I wasn’t very active in it. And then when I came out to New York, I just happened to get a job at a gym as one of my side jobs. Some of the other trainers there started teaching me about weightlifting and HIIT training. And it just had this crazy click moment for me: This is the coolest thing I’ve ever done. You can get strong and fit, eat more food, and look the way you want to look. And it’s fantastic. And as a dancer, you get injured a lot. So the more you can cross train, the stronger you can get, the less you’re going to get hurt. And so I just kind of channeled that because New York City is definitely not the biggest fitness industry, but it’s one of the top fitness industries. So there’s a lot of opportunities here. And I just kept kind of snowballing with that and getting my group fitness certification and getting my personal training certification.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Great. Going back to your UCI experience, you also worked in some capacity with the admissions department. So can you tell me a little bit about that?

Shira at UCI: Yeah, I was a student ambassador for about a year. That involved going to a lot of fairs and going to different high school and outreach events and talking to prospective students about UC Irvine.

Mercy at SocratesPost: How did you get involved in that?

Shira at UCI: I applied for it. I think I had some friends who were in the program. Previously, I had also worked for the scholarship opportunities program. And that was a job helping students at UCI apply for outside prestigious scholarships. So I had a little bit of experience being employed by UCI.

Mercy at SocratesPost: What surprised you most about working in admissions? You said you went to college fairs and high schools to speak to students.

Shira at UCI: I don’t remember too many surprises. I think that everything that people know UCI for right now is true. They recruit and are passionate about a lot of first generation and minority students. And that’s a really big push for them.

I really like talking to people and meeting new people, so it was a fun opportunity to talk with them about UCI.

Mercy at SocratesPost: What were some common questions that prospective students would ask you?

Shira at UCI: I think the things that are usually outside of academia is what they’re mostly interested: student culture surrounding Irvine and Newport Beach. We do have a lot of people interested in the Criminal Justice programs, because that’s something that’s pretty unique to UCI. Those are the two main things that I remember getting asked about.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Okay. And when you were acting as a student ambassador answering questions, did you have any sort of evaluative role in applicants at all like recommending students to the admissions officers?

Shira at UCI: No, I didn’t have any role like that.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Okay. You’ve gone through the process of getting into UCI and going through four years and graduating. What do you think is the biggest misunderstanding that prospective students have about getting into UCI or being a student there?

Shira at UCI: It’s been quite a few years now since I applied and even since I graduated. UCI’s gone up in prestige since I graduated. For a lot of people and myself included, it was kind of seen as the backup option at that time. And for me, it was close to home and so that was kind of the reason why I ended up going there. Overall, it’s a really good school. It’s a beautiful campus.

And what I would say is that college, especially right now, is what you make of it. Definitely encourage people to get that four year degree, but maybe take a year before you go into it and have a better idea of what you’re committing yourself to, especially financially. Because though I’m very grateful for the time that I spent there, and I do think that I learned a lot, at the same time, there’s so many other ways to learn right now. And I don’t know if everyone needs to jump headfirst into a four year degree, especially when you don’t know what you want.

I started undeclared and thought I’m going to do linguistics, I like business, I like psychology, I like science. So I spent quite a while trying to figure out what I wanted to be studying.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Okay, yeah, that’s a really good point. It’s like, if you’re not sure this is the right path for you spend some time, maybe take a gap year to figure it out before you commit.

Shira at UCI: Yeah. You could even work remotely, or travel or something like that and get some experience and then still go to school.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Oh, yeah, absolutely. How would you describe the culture of the UCI admissions office? Like how did the co workers and admissions reps interact with each other?

Shira at UCI: It was a fun environment. And I’d say that it’s in a similar vein to people that lead tours: people that enjoy people and enjoy talking to people. And even our bosses were friendly. I think that those sorts of positions require that type of person, kind of like a camp counselor or guide.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Makes sense. Were there any pieces of information or secrets that higher ups didn’t want you to share with students?

Subscribe to read what types of applicants impressed Shira, why personal statements aren’t as important as portfolios for dance majors, how to best audition, and what questions to ask yourself as an aspiring dancer applying to college →
Here’s a preview of the rest of our conversation! Subscribe to read the rest and support our ad-free newsletter.

Mercy at SocratesPost: When you encountered students, what types of students impressed you the most?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Absolutely. Having done your four years at UCI, you’ve probably met so many other students and peers. What type of person do you think, just had the highest rate of success? Or had the best time at UCI? What types of people really do well there?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Okay, yeah, that makes sense. Like having a more of a well rounded experience, not just focusing on academics, but exploring career options and your social life.

If you could redo anything that you did as a student in college, what would you redo?

Mercy at SocratesPost: For those who are interested in doing what you do now, being a professional dancer working in the fitness industry, how important do you think college is for that type of career?

Mercy at SocratesPost: That’s really insightful. What about getting into a dance major or conservatory? What types of advice do you have for students who really enjoy dancing, that think they might want to pursue that later on? How should they prepare their application or portfolio?

Mercy at SocratesPost: And how does the application essay play a part in that? Because, of course, for dance majors that might be more important than what you bring to the dance community on campus. But do you think that the personal statement has a pretty important role as well?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Okay, cool. Earlier, you were talking about how you did double degrees in both dance and business administration, and clearly you do a lot of dance because you’re a professional dancer. In what ways have you used your business degree?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Absolutely. I also wanted to learn a little bit more about your dance career. You said you’re a professional dancer. So in what capacity do you dance? Are you involved in more theater type dance or dance instruction?

Mercy at SocratesPost: What’s the audition scene like there for professional dancers?

Mercy at SocratesPost: How do you stand out amongst that? It seems like it’s pretty cutthroat.

Mercy at SocratesPost: Yeah, it’s like a silver lining is you become well-versed in everything because you can’t just focus on one skill. Do you ever fantasize about a different career? Have you ever thought to leave dance or fitness behind for something different or new?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Okay, Shira, what is your best piece of advice for a student wanting to go to UCI?

Mercy at SocratesPost: How should students find individuals who are willing to talk to them and share their experience?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Do you have any advice for students who want to study dance, in college, whether it’s a UCI or a different school?

Mercy at SocratesPost: Thanks so much for your time today, Shira.

This concludes our exclusive insider interview with Shira Jackman! Stay tuned for a brand new exclusive insider interview next week.

Dear Socrates Q&A

This week, we selected a question from L:

“What is the one piece of advice you would give to someone trying to get into Northwestern?”

This was one of the questions submitted for the interview with a Northwestern admissions director. Even though it wasn’t selected, it’s a good question that we have some insight on. In total, we’ve been involved with Northwestern admissions in some capacity for 7 years.

Demonstrate commitment to Northwestern. Ever since I was an applicant, I’ve noticed that NU loves it when you show commitment. Why?

1. I’ve interviewed NU applicants every year since graduating. One of the questions the admissions office asks me to report is “how interested or committed does this student appear to be in NU?” They wouldn’t ask if they didn’t care. Students to whom I offered an interview but did not accept or show up never got accepted. The first way to show you’re interested is to make time for the interview and actually show up.

Want advice?

Join our e-mail list and submit your question to the weekly Dear Socrates advice column.

Subscription Error? Start here

SocratesPost is always on the frontlines scouring the news for relevant updates in the college admissions landscape. We look for anything that can help shape our understanding of the latest trends in admissions and help our readers see the direction in which we’re moving. Questions we explored this week:

  • This week, Harvard rescinded an admittance from a survivor of a high school shooting. Why?
  • How is Duke going to use the SAT adversity score? Finally, a response from Duke’s admissions dean
  • Here’s one way to improve college students’ attendance: track them. Who is doing this and how?

Get answers below.

June 18, 2019 — He posted racist statements online.

Kyle Kashuv, a pro-gun and pro-Trump Parkland shooting survivor, had gotten into Harvard. However, admissions officials discovered his racist statements posted on his social media at age 16. They revoked his admittance and despite Kyle’s public apology, did not budge on their decision.

What does this mean? Whatever you post on the Internet is like a tattoo: you can’t guarantee it’ll go away when you no longer think it serves you. Be very polite or nonexistent online and remember that colleges can look you up and see your digital footprint history.

June 18, 2019 — It “may influence a ‘small number of applications on the border between two decisions’”

Dean Christoph Guttentag said he isn’t sure how exactly the adversity score will be used but it will be considered in admissions. He said it may come in handy if an application reader is unfamiliar with a particular high school, but thinks it’s rare that such a score will make or break a decision. He sees benefits and limitations. In an email to The Chronicle, Dean Guttentag wrote:

“Just like college rankings, single scores of a complex combination of attributes are always reductive, but the component scores may be useful as guideposts. I expect that when we do use [the score], we will use it as insight into a student’s environmental context, more than as a measure of adversity.”