“Do you see coding bootcamps or other forms of shorter, less expensive professional education eventually being a desired alternative to four-year colleges?”
– Zachary from San Francisco

Coding bootcamps have already become a desired alternative. No need to wait for it to “eventually” become an alternative to four-year colleges.
Online academies like AppAcademy, General Assembly, Flatiron School, Coding Dojo, etc. have popped up in recent years as a response to the demand for coders in Silicon Valley to support the tech scene.
Most of these academies don’t require any previous professional experience. Admission involves solving coding problems and an interview — much less complicated than the traditional admissions requirements for four year degrees.
The difference is that most of these online coding academies guarantee a job as a software developer or programmer and don’t charge tuition until you’ve been hired. They advertise high average starting salaries for most of their graduates, ranging upwards of $110k.

App Academy only asks for tuition once hired as a developer.

Flatiron School offers a money-back guarantee for students who don’t land jobs within six months. Tuition costs about $15,000.

Thinkful only asks for tuition after you’re hired — at 15% of your income.Your typical college won’t give you a refund if you can’t land a job in your field after graduation. They most certainly won’t defer tuition until you sign an offer.
Unlike traditional Bachelor’s programs that aim to instill more than job skills, these alternative institutions focus on teaching practical, on-the-job, pre-professional skills in an intensive, immersive, and fast-paced environment.
With concerns of unemployment among recent college graduates, these online coding schools offer a more predictable educational investment.
However, despite the boom in coding schools, there’ve been some failed academies. Dev Bootcamp (a Kaplan-owned company) and Iron Yard (a University of Phoenix-owned company) both shut down operations in 2017. The main reason? Not keeping up with employer demands.
Coding is not exactly timeless. Even recent graduates and fresh developers need to keep up with technological trends that change almost daily. When schools teach on-the-job skills rather than critical thinking, logic, and adaptability, those graduates become less relevant in the workforce. After all, they’re only equipped to solve extremely specific and finite problems that they were trained to address. Aside from that, they might not have the requisite skills to transfer their 12-week programming education into a new direction their tech startup is pursuing.
These academies tend to be a launchpad to a career and a job. They might be suitable for working parents or young people who are determined to commit to a certain career. They might be constrained by money and need to get in and out in 16-weeks or 10 months, or whatever the term is. What these schools don’t offer, though, is the time to explore oneself.
These programs might appeal to an older population who may have already completed an undergraduate program and may have already racked up a few years of work experience. For younger students, jumping directly into a job-focused trade school might risk missing the opportunity to explore different career possibilities, do research, pursue interdisciplinary studies, engage in extracurriculars and hobbies, develop intimate relationships with peers.
Ultimately, before these schools, most working adults wanting a career change went back to school to get a degree. Despite the flexibility of university extension programs or “night school” that focused on gaining professional skills (think Columbia’s M.S. in Information and Knowledge Strategy or Northwestern’s M.S. in Sports Administration), this option was time-consuming and expensive. Tuition was $40k+.

December 2018 screenshot from Northwestern’s M.S. in Sports Administration tuition page showing an estimated cost of $40k+.
The coding academies offer a more straightforward alternative that instills the confidence students need to invest in themselves and envision a career transformation.
I still believe that it will be awhile before we see your typical American high school students jumping straight to coding academy instead of going to a 2- or 4-year college. At that age, there’s just too much to learn about the world and oneself to commit to such a narrow focus. However, for adult learners or degree-holding professionals looking for a career change, I see these bootcamps as a reasonable alternative to traditional degrees.
